Published on
The File Can Travel—Trust Must Travel with It
Institutions are solving two different digital credentialing problems: making the credential work inside the institution and making the trust attached to it work beyond it.
We have become much better at the first problem. Universities can implement secure platforms, integrate credentialing with existing systems, establish privacy and governance processes, and give learners faster access to authenticated records.
The second problem begins when the credential leaves us. I came to that conclusion after interviewing 43 registrars and information technology leaders at 31 Canadian universities. The research examined how institutions accepted and implemented digital credentials and what happened as those credentials began circulating beyond the universities that issued them.What became clear is that successful implementation inside the university does not guarantee that the credential will work equally well outside it. That matters because credentials are meant to travel.
Implementation Is Only the First Problem
Most institutions in my study did not begin digital credentialing because they wanted to reinvent the credential. They were trying to solve practical problems. Paper processes were cumbersome, verification took time, fraud was a concern, COVID-19 disrupted established practices, and students were asking for faster access to their records. A smaller number approached digital credentialing primarily as an innovation opportunity.More ambitious innovation could open possibilities that incremental implementation did not, but it could also become vulnerable with leadership changes, costs becoming harder to justify or too much dependence on individual champions. Problem-driven implementation had a clearer operational rationale and often provided a strong foundation for subsequent strategic thinking.
The practical lesson is straightforward: Start with something real, but do not confuse solving the internal problem with completing the transformation. Go-live only tells us that the institution can issue the credential. It does not tell us what happens when someone else receives it.
Trust Has a Receiving End
A learner may present a digital credential to another university, an employer, a regulator, a professional body, a government agency or an organization in another country. At that moment, institutional control ends.
One registrar in my study described situations in which foreign organizations continued to require paper transcripts even though the university could provide authenticated digital records. The institution maintained a paper option rather than leave students unable to meet those requirements. That example captures the larger problem. The credential was legitimate. The university trusted the process. The technology worked. None of that guaranteed recognition at the receiving end.
Other participants described very different experiences. Some receivers accepted digital records routinely. Some increasingly expected them. In other cases, institutions had very little visibility into what happened after learners shared their credentials. For this reason, lack of use should not automatically be interpreted as lack of trust.
A receiver that does not use the credential may not distrust it. Perhaps the organization is unfamiliar with it. Its procedures are still built around paper. Its systems cannot process digital verification. Its staff do not know what to do with the verification link. Or it has not yet seen enough digital credentials for a new practice to form.
Those are different problems, and treating them all as resistance obscures what institutions actually need to address. It is an ecosystem trust problem. A credential may be technically portable while the trust supporting it is not equally portable.
Look Outward Earlier
Universities understandably spend enormous effort looking inward when implementing digital credentials. Can the platform integrate with the student information system? Have privacy and security requirements been met? Who has authority to issue the credential? What governance is required? How will staff support it? What will it cost? All those questions matter.
However, institutions should begin looking outward much earlier. Before implementation is complete, we should be asking: Who is expected to receive this credential? What will they see? How will they know who issued it? Will they understand how to verify it? Can their systems and procedures accommodate it? And what happens to the learner when they cannot?
We often describe digital credentials as tools for learner mobility, but mobility is not created simply because a learner can download or share a record through a platform. The credential has to remain meaningful when it crosses a boundary. That may be a boundary between universities, between education and employment, between a university and a professional regulator or across national systems that operate under very different assumptions about what constitutes an official academic record. If the receiver cannot understand or act on the credential, the learner still encounters friction even though the record itself is digital and verifiable.
Employer Engagement Matters, but We Need Better Evidence
Employers are an obvious part of this conversation, particularly as institutions explore credentials intended to communicate skills and learning more directly, but we should be careful about claiming to know what employers think. My study interviewed university registrars and IT leaders, not employers. It therefore cannot establish whether employers trust, value or use digital credentials. What it did reveal was how little issuing institutions often knew about what happened after learners shared those credentials externally.
Issuing practices have evolved, but receiving practices have not necessarily evolved at the same pace. If higher education wants digital credentials to create value beyond administrative efficiency, we need much stronger engagement with the organizations expected to receive and act on them.
That means moving beyond asking whether employers have heard of digital credentials. We need to understand how credentials enter real hiring, verification and decision-making processes and where those processes break down.
Two Questions Matter More than Go-Live
For institutions beginning or scaling this work, I would put two questions at the center of the conversation.
Who needs to recognize this credential outside our institution?
Identify the likely receivers before launch. Their ability to understand, verify and use the credential is not an external issue to be dealt with later. It is part of the implementation problem.
What will success look like for the learner?
Success is not simply the number of credentials issued or the percentage of students who activate a digital record. The more meaningful test is whether learners can carry, share and use those credentials when and where they need them.
Digital credentialing is often described as a technology transformation, but that description is sufficient. Technology is one component of a much larger infrastructure of governance, institutional authority, professional relationships, receiver practices and trust.
The real test comes after go-live, when a learner carries a credential somewhere the university does not control. Does the receiving organization understand it? Does it trust the assurance behind it? Can it act on it?
When the answer to those questions is yes, digital credentialing becomes more than institutional modernization. It becomes infrastructure for learner mobility because the credential can travel with the trust that gives it meaning.