The College-to-Career Pathway Needs a Redesign

The College-to-Career Pathway Needs a Redesign
Students need an accessible, adaptable and affordable educational pathway that takes into account workforce needs, competing responsibilities and professional experience.

Degree apprenticeships let learners earn a degree, build experience and move up at work without choosing among them.

For generations, the college-to-career path has followed a familiar sequence: stop working, enroll, borrow, graduate, then look for a job that rewards the degree. Nearly all the risk lands on the learner, and most of it lands before they see any return.

The costs of that design are becoming harder to ignore. The advocacy group Protect Borrowers estimates that nearly 9 million people were in default on federal student loans at the end of 2025. The U.S. Department of Education announced plans to restart involuntary collections, including wage garnishment, but delayed implementation on Jan. 16, 2026. Its announcement did not set a new start date.

I’ve spent my career working across two worlds that still don’t talk to each other enough: higher education and the workplace. Degree apprenticeships offer a way to connect them. Learners earn a degree, build relevant experience and progress at work at the same time.

Build Learning Around the Learner’s Working Life

The traditional sequence assumes learners can put work on hold while they study. Many adults can’t. They’re balancing rent, caregiving and jobs they can’t afford to leave. For them, “Stop working and go to school” isn’t a plan. It’s a bet.

Years of work experience may be directly relevant to a learner’s next role, yet that experience does not always translate into academic progress. Higher education has treated work and learning as separate lives. Learners pay for that separation.

A degree apprenticeship starts with employment. The learner receives pay while working toward a degree related to the job or career they are pursuing. Employers and public funding often cover or offset tuition, so learners borrow far less.

Coursework and on-the-job learning are designed to reinforce each other. When workplace competencies align with academic requirements, institutions can assess documented learning for credit. That process has to be rigorous. Faculty need evidence they can evaluate, and every program should be clear about what counts toward the degree and what counts toward the apprenticeship credential.

Experience Should Count Toward Advancement

In a conventional pathway, substantial work experience often comes after the degree. In a degree apprenticeship, relevant work is part of the learning design. Apprentices apply what they study to real problems and receive guidance from supervisors and mentors who can observe their progress.

Graduates can leave with more than a credential. They also have a documented record of work in their field and an employer who has seen their skills develop. That experience is particularly valuable for learners who have not had access to professional networks or traditional entry-level opportunities.

The model isn’t new. England has offered degree apprenticeships since 2015. In the United States, employers, colleges and states are exploring how apprenticeship structures can extend beyond the skilled trades into fields such as education and health care.

North Carolina Puts the Model to Work

Here’s what that looks like in North Carolina. Through a five-year, $5.5 million federal Teacher Quality Partnership grant, Western Governors University and Craft Education are partnering with The Innovation Project, a collaborative of North Carolina school districts, to prepare 500 teacher apprentices and train 250 mentoring teachers starting in fall 2027.

The workforce need is significant. The North Carolina Department of Public Instruction reported 2,009 teacher vacancies at the start of the school year, according to the N.C. Department of Public Instruction.

The initiative is designed to help school employees, including teacher assistants, work toward bachelor’s degrees in elementary or special education while remaining employed by their districts. Apprentices will complete the program’s academic and classroom requirements and pursue a North Carolina teaching license and a registered apprenticeship credential.

We also take the paperwork off districts’ plates. Craft handles tracking hours, funding and federal reporting, so districts can focus on developing teachers and keep the program running after the grant ends.

For employers, this is a talent strategy, not a perk. In fields, such as education, facing persistent staffing challenges, school districts can develop talent among people already on their payroll. Many are teacher assistants who already know the students, the school and the community. What they’ve been missing is a way to earn a license without giving up a paycheck.

What Higher Education Leaders Can Do Now

For colleges, the shift requires close collaboration with employers, thoughtful assessment of learning outside the classroom and a willingness to treat the workplace as a learning environment. It also calls for clear academic standards, as recognizing demonstrated skills should not mean lowering expectations.

Start with the employers already asking. Hospitals, school districts and large employers with hard-to-fill roles are often the most willing partners. Then, credit what learners already know, with assessments that recognize skills demonstrated on the job.

Design for the workday, so apprentices can learn without leaving the job that pays them. And build the career ladder into the program itself, so each stage of learning lines up with a step up at work.

States can help. California has already surpassed its goal of creating 500,000 earn-and-learn opportunities by 2029. As of October 2026, the state reported more than 694,000 such opportunities since 2019, including nearly 267,000 registered apprenticeships. In 2025, California allocated and awarded more than $240 million toward high-quality apprenticeship programs; in October 2026, it announced an additional $44.4 million investment to train 49,000 apprentices. Most of that growth is in the trades. The next step is making room for degree apprenticeships in state funding rules and financial aid policy.

Rebuild the Pathway

Student loan default is a lagging indicator. It can signal a breakdown between the cost of education, the credential a learner earns and the opportunities that follow.

We can’t undo the choices or circumstances that brought today’s borrowers into default. We can, however, redesign pathways for future learners, so paid work and higher education reinforce one another. When experience is recognized, learning fits into working life and credentials connect to career progression. Earning a degree stops being a pause in a career and becomes the way forward.