Does It Pay for Adults to Return to Higher Education? (Part 1)
While the value of a college degree is being consistently brought into question, the statistics show degree-holders are significantly better off in tough economic times.

I have a friend who is considering a return to college. He stopped out of Big State U several years ago and has worked in unsatisfying jobs since. He is wondering if the time, effort and money he would have to invest to complete his degree are worth it. Will it really make a difference in his career options? Will he just accumulate more debt and be stuck in the same place? Is completing a bachelor’s degree worth it?

The answer is, “Yes, of course it is!”

Education has mattered enormously during this recent recessionary period, in terms of helping individuals to avoid unemployment and garner higher wages. Those with only a high school education have continued to lose jobs throughout the entire recession, and their wages have slid lower. An associate’s degree improves prospects. A bachelor’s degree improves wages and employment even more. A graduate degree adds to your chances of positive employment and wage outcomes. The bottom line is: more education matters.

But, wait, what about those recent graduates living at home?

We all know someone who has completed degrees and is not flourishing and someone who stopped formal education after high school who is doing well.  Despite these individual counter-examples, the economic data make it clear that holding a bachelor’s degree is an enormous advantage. During the more recent period of slow recovery, job growth has largely gone to those with a bachelor’s degree or higher. Georgetown’s Center on Education and the Workforce report titled “Weathering the Storm” stated:

“More than half of the employment increases have gone to workers with a bachelor’s degree or better, the rest of the gains to those with some college education or an associate’s degree.  Even in the recovery, workers with only a high school diploma or less have continued to lose jobs.”

While the size of the job market for college graduates has increased more slowly than in the past, the odds still strongly favor those with a bachelor’s degree or higher. The broader direction of the economy points towards this becoming a stronger, not weaker, trend. The chart on page five of “Weathering the Storm” illustrates that point.

What about wages?  I don’t want to have $25,000 in debt to make only $30,000 a year.

A new report from the State Higher Education Executive Officers pointed out that skepticism about the value of a college degree in terms of wage outcomes is just off base:

“…The evidence clearly demonstrates the value of a college education. According to our analysis of U.S. Census data, those who obtain a bachelor’s degree have a median income of $50,360 compared to a median of $29,423 for people with only a high school diploma. An associate’s degree leads to a median income of $38,607, more than $9,000 higher than a high school diploma. Those with a graduate degree have a median income of $68,064, 35.2 percent more than those with a bachelor’s degree.”

Let’s work with that wage differential. How long does it take to pay off the cost of the degree, and what’s the lifetime advantage? Whether we consider the bachelor’s advantage over the associate’s degree ($11,000 a year) or the high school degree ($21,000 a year), it takes only a few short years to pay the direct costs. The lifetime advantage will be upwards of $400,000, according to the Census Bureau.

OK, does it matter which major I choose?

In some ways, no. Completion of the degree is what matters. However, not all degrees are created equal. For one thing, the degree does need to come from a reputable source to be helpful in a job search. We also know that, in general, the more quantitative or technical the degree, the better the lifetime outcomes will be. For instance, there is great demand currently for health-related degrees, and graduates from those programs are getting good starting wages. However, over the course of their careers, graduates in engineering, science and business will get the greatest bang for their buck. In IT, those who create information will do better than those who use information. These insights come from another recent study from the Georgetown Center on Education and the Workforce.  All that said, completion of a degree matters. For those with experience, the major may be less important than simply finishing the degree.

I’ve seen those commercials from a for-profit college — is that a good option?

It does matter where you get your degree. In one study from the National Bureau of Economic Research, graduates from for-profits saw very little impact on earnings after degree completion, even after controlling for other characteristics that might affect wages. The study found “large, statistically significant benefits from obtaining certificates/degrees from public and not-for-profit but not from for-profit institutions.” Another study indicated that hiring managers preferred graduates from traditional programs over those from identifiably online universities.  When hiring managers were presented with sets of identical candidates, with the only variation being the source of the degree, “96 percent chose the hypothetical applicant with the traditional degree.” The Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions recently published a large study on the major problems they found with the large for-profit colleges.  There are plenty of adult-focused colleges that are non-profit or public, that provide credible degree completion programs with accelerated and online options.

Is it really that simple? Does completing my degree get me the job I want?

The key is having both the needed experience and the credential (the degree). In my career, I serve adult degree completion students, and roughly half of them are completing their degrees in order to secure their career or to move up from where they currently work. They typically do not need added experience, just the degree. Another 40 percent are seeking a degree in order to gain entry into a new field.  While they’re working on their degrees, we help them gain experience in the target profession so they can make the most of the degree when they finish.

Please come back next week for the conclusion of this series, where Pearson looks at some different ways adult students can fund their continuing higher education.

Print Friendly
Subscribe to Evo

Readers Comments

Tyrese Banner 2013/02/14 at 8:24 am

As an academic advisor at an institution where about 45 percent of our enrollment comes from adult students, this article resonated with me (and, I’m sure, others in my profession). I think the media has done somewhat of a disservice to the public with their stories of growing student debt, graduates working in low-wage sectors, high unemployment, etc. such that, when I speak to potential adult students, their first question is always, “Well, if a 25-year-old with a college degree can’t get a break, what hope is there for me?”

I always tell them that education is a worthwhile investment, but it’s a long-term one. The benefits of having a degree grow over time, as the author points out, and I advise patience (although that’s not always easy when you’re speaking to someone who’s further along in life). I found the information in this article helpful and will be sure to point to it the next time a potential adult student comes in to see me.

    Dr. Walter Pearson 2013/02/15 at 2:44 pm

    Thanks Tyrese! The next piece will cover ideas for making the degree more affordable. Hope this is helpful in your work.

    Walt

Christopher Gillies 2013/02/14 at 9:41 am

It should be noted that the authors of the not for profit vs for profit schools come from Boston University (an allegedly ‘not for profit’ school) and “the researchers focused on those starting certificate and associate degree programs”.

One can argue that a learner who is physically disabled could benefit from an online university, but the battle will continue between not for profit vs for profit schools as they need students to keep them in existence.

Dr. Walter Pearson 2013/02/14 at 1:07 pm

Hi Christopher – I am a strong believer in online education. In my view, adult students should choose a respected institution when considering the degree program that they can fit into their life. In general, this is going to be one of the not-for-profit or public institutions, where online programs are also widely available. Please look through the report from the U. S. Senate on the state of the for-profit institutions. It is chilling.

Walt

Greg Allen 2013/02/14 at 3:29 pm

I find it quite troubling that employers tend to distrust degrees earned entirely online. In my mind, online education is one of the best ways to ensure that non-traditional students, who may not be able to work on-campus courses into their schedules, have access to education. I understand that employers might want to make a distinction between an unknown for-profit institution granting degrees online and a reputable university offering online programming, but it would be a shame if they painted all online programs with the same brush.

Dr. Walter Pearson 2013/02/15 at 1:11 pm

Hi Greg – It is a bit hard to untangle if this reaction is more to the for-profit institution than to the delivery model. We understand that learning online can produce at least equal, if not superior, outcomes.

Walt

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

[if lte IE 8]
[if lte IE 8]